Head to head

Charter Arms Bulldog vs S&W 642

Five rounds either way. The question is bore diameter against everything else.

Charter Arms Bulldog .44 Special

Approximate manufacturer figures. Confirm on the merchant listing before buying.
Capacity	5 rounds
Chambering	.44 Special
Barrel	2.5"
Weight	~21 oz
Frame	Stainless
Action	Double / single action

Illustrative rendering — see merchant listing for actual product photos.

Check current price

S&W Model 642 Airweight

Approximate manufacturer figures. Confirm on the merchant listing before buying.
Capacity	5 rounds
Chambering	.38 Special +P
Barrel	1.9"
Weight	~15 oz
Frame	Alloy J-frame
Action	Double-action only, shrouded hammer

Illustrative rendering — see merchant listing for actual product photos.

Check current price

Where they actually differ

	Charter Arms Bulldog .44 Special	S&W Model 642 Airweight
Ammunition cost and choice	.44 Special: expensive, limited selection	.38 Special: cheap, everywhere, enormous selection
Recoil character	Heavy push, slower impulse	Sharp snap, especially with +P
Carry weight	Noticeably heavier and thicker	About as light as a functional revolver gets

The verdict

The 642 is the more sensible gun for almost everyone: cheaper and far more available ammunition, lighter carry, better holster support, and a much deeper parts supply. The Bulldog's case is bore diameter — a .44 caliber bullet at modest velocity, with a push of recoil rather than a whip crack. That is a real and defensible preference, but you pay for it at the ammunition counter every single range trip.

Common questions

Is .44 Special hard to find?

Harder than .38 Special and usually two to three times the price. Plan on buying in bulk when you see it, and expect a much shorter list of defensive loads to choose from.

Does bigger bore diameter matter that much?

It is one variable among several, and penetration and shot placement matter more than frontal area. A .44 Special that does not expand still makes a larger hole than a .38 that does not expand, which is the honest version of the argument for it.

Which is easier to shoot well?

The 642, mostly because you will shoot it far more often for the same money.

Check the law where you live. Firearms transfer through a licensed dealer where required, and state and local rules differ on what may be bought, shipped, or carried. Verify before you order.

← All comparisons